When I decided to do my John Carpenter marathon, I debated skipping this movie. What review could I write that would anything new to this heavily-discussed masterpiece? Is there anything to add to the discussion at this point, 48 years later? In some ways, it is easier to discuss the sequels (and their wide range of quality) than the original, since - outside of Halloween II (1981) - they are much less discussed and picked-apart as this one.
This is, quite literally, a perfect horror movie. Moody, atmospheric, almost elemental in its storytelling, it's not surprising that the movie is credited (incorrectly, I might add) with being the first slasher - while Black Christmas and The Texas Chainsaw Massacre predate it, the influence this film had vastly outshines those films, great though they are.
The film almost reads better as a fable: this is a battle between Good (Laurie Strode, famously played by Jamie Lee Curtis in a star-making performance) and Evil (The Shape - sometimes called Michael Myers - as played by Nick Castle). Only the pure can survive the corruption of Evil's creation, and God help anyone else who encounters it.
The film also has it's soothsayer in Donald Pleasence's performance as Dr. Sam Loomis, one of the all-time great horror performances (expect me to make that statement in several of Carpenter's upcoming films - part of his legacy is ushering in some of the best the genre has ever seen). His various monologues and asides provide just the right amount of heightened surrealism to the movie that gives it that elemental feel.
Carpenter also did composing work for this film, and created one of the best musical scores of all time, with the title theme being recognizable to even the most unlearned of movie buffs. The cinematography - done by Dean Cundey - is also a standout part of the film. Bright yellows during the daytime, and an almost impossible blue to the night scenes, Cundey's contributions cannot be understated.
This is one of those horror movies that I think everyone should watch. Not just because I am a fan of horror, but because it is a standout in a genre that has far more duds than it has masterpieces.
10 out of 10.
(A fun aside: One of the movies watched during the babysitting scenes is 1951's The Thing From Another World - a movie that Carpenter would remake 6 years later)